I always wear some sort of powder...for the most part my skin stays clear, but I do get a bit shiny sometimes. I saw Boots Time Dimensions facial balm at Target on sale from $17 down to $8 and change. I've been using it when I wash my face both in the morning and at night, but at night I use a night cream to go along with it. I've been using it for a week...my face hasn't been getting shiny. It says nothing about controlling shine, but for some reason it has that effect for me.
My only complaint is that when I look really close up in certain lighting I see tiny pink shimmer. I don't like shimmer all over my face, but like I said it's only visible very close up. I wish it contained SPF too.
It gives this soft glow that the photo doesn't capture, but you can see that my face is shine free. I have absolutely no face makeup on(foundation, concealer, powder, blush...obviously I have on a little eye makeup :D). I took this without flash since flash is often a little too flattering to skin sometimes. The lighting in my house seems a little too unflattering though :P.
Here it is